I went through what you posted, Ken, and ensured everything was set correctly. Also went through and looked over everything- to my eye, it's all good. Got it all dialed in, but still having the same problem.
It can't be off much, but just enough where you can get a good cut in the middle of the cutter, but a "light" cut on the right side. (or conversely, cutting paper in the center, and getting a good cut on the right). It's not a disaster, just makes weeding some of the stuff hell... (mind you, I primarily use this for small cuts (as small as 3/16" letters).